· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte
Deutsch · English · Français · Español
Anyone who sells goods or services through dealers, franchisees or platforms concludes contracts every day that are relevant under competition law. The Vertical Block Exemption Regulation (Regulation 2022/720) and its guidelines set the framework. Mistakes lead to void clauses, fines and damages claims by dealers.
Basic structure
Agreements between companies at different levels of the supply chain are exempted if the supplier’s share of the selling market and the buyer’s share of the purchasing market each do not exceed 30% and no hardcore restriction under Article 4 is agreed. Certain clauses, such as non-compete obligations of more than five years, are not exempted under Article 5 but leave the rest of the contract unaffected.
Hardcore restrictions
- Fixed or minimum resale prices of the dealer
- Territorial and customer restrictions, unless one of the exceptions applies (for example protection of an exclusive territory against active sales)
- Restrictions of cross-supplies within selective distribution systems
- Preventing the effective use of the internet for sales
Changes since 2022
The 2022 regulation addresses dual distribution, where a manufacturer also sells directly to end customers and thus competes with its dealers. Information exchange is only exempted there insofar as it is necessary to implement the distribution agreement. Shared exclusivity with up to five dealers per territory is permitted, dual pricing for online and offline sales is possible in principle, and wide parity clauses of platforms are no longer exempted. The regulation applies until 31 May 2034.
Our services
- Review and redesign of existing distribution agreements and dealer terms
- Set-up of exclusive, selective and franchise distribution systems
- Online sales policies and marketplace rules
- Defence in proceedings concerning resale price maintenance or territorial protection
- Enforcement or defence of supply claims
Case examples
Praxisbeispiel 1: New exclusive distribution system in Eastern Europe
An agricultural machinery manufacturer wants to appoint one exclusive dealer each in Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia and protect them against competition from other dealers.
The regulation allows active sales by other dealers into the exclusive territory to be prohibited; passive sales, that is unsolicited customer requests, must remain permitted. We drafted the contracts accordingly and checked market shares for each country.
Praxisbeispiel 2: Manufacturer sells online itself
A furniture manufacturer opens its own online shop and wants to receive monthly sell-out data per item and store from its dealers.
Because of dual distribution, we examined which data is actually needed to manage the dealer network. We limited the request to stock levels and aggregated sales and ensured that the data does not reach the online shop team.
Praxisbeispiel 3: Termination of a dealer for online sales
A dealer sells branded tools in its own online shop well below the recommended price. The manufacturer wants to terminate the contract.
A termination based on undercutting the recommended price would be prohibited resale price maintenance. We advised the manufacturer instead to lay down qualitative requirements for online presence in a policy that applies equally to all dealers.
Praxisbeispiel 4: Franchise system in system catering
A franchisor wants to require franchisees to buy all ingredients from designated suppliers and to set maximum prices for promotions.
Purchasing obligations are permitted insofar as they are necessary to protect the identity and know-how of the system. Maximum prices are allowed as long as they do not in fact operate as fixed or minimum prices. We adapted the manual and designed the promotional prices as genuine maximum prices.
Typical situations and industries
Further topics
- Dawn Raids by Competition Authorities
- Cartels, Price Fixing and Leniency
- Competition Compliance and Internal Investigations
- Merger Control in Germany
- EU Merger Control and Referrals
- International Merger Control and Multi-Jurisdictional Filings
- Foreign Direct Investment Screening in Germany
- Abuse of Dominance
- Digital Platforms: Section 19a GWB and the Digital Markets Act
- Cartel Damages Claims in Germany
- Fees
Discuss your matter
Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.
The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.
