· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte
Deutsch · English · Français · Español
Energy and water supply are often regional monopolies. That is why stricter rules against price abuse apply, and the competition authorities scrutinise water and district heating prices closely. At the same time, the energy transition requires cooperation, for example in networks, heating and charging infrastructure.
Typical issues
- Price abuse: Section 29 GWB for electricity and gas, Section 31 GWB for water, general abuse control for district heating
- Third-party access to heating networks and charging infrastructure
- Cooperation and shareholdings between municipal utilities, merger control
- Concession awards for electricity, gas and water networks
- Long-term supply contracts and exclusivity
- Fuels: special rules for refineries and wholesale (Section 29a GWB)
Special features
The competition authorities of the German federal states are responsible for many regional suppliers. Price proceedings are conducted using comparable markets and cost reviews; the burden of proof can lie with the supplier. Municipal companies are subject to competition law just like private ones.
Practical examples
Practical example 1: District heating prices under review
A state competition authority opens proceedings for excessive district heating prices.
We prepared the supplier’s cost structure and challenged the comparable markets; the proceedings ended with a moderate adjustment.
Practical example 2: Joint sales by municipal utilities
Five municipal utilities want to market a joint green electricity tariff.
We structured the cooperation so that each utility sets its own end-customer prices.
Practical example 3: Access to sites for charging stations
A charging station operator is denied sites by a municipal company.
We prepared a complaint to the state competition authority and an action for equal treatment; the company introduced a non-discriminatory award procedure.
Practical example 4: Water price proceedings
A water supplier is required to make repayments.
We demonstrated structural differences from the comparison companies; the repayment demand was significantly reduced.
Frequently asked questions
Do special rules against price abuse apply to energy suppliers?
Yes. Section 29 GWB tightens abuse control for electricity and gas; the burden of proving that prices are appropriate can lie with the supplier. Section 31 GWB applies to water, general abuse control to district heating.
Are municipal utilities subject to competition law?
Yes. Municipal companies are bound by competition law just like private companies, including merger control and the prohibition of abuse.
Who handles price proceedings against regional suppliers?
Usually the competition authority of the federal state if the conduct is limited to one state. If effects extend beyond one state, the Bundeskartellamt is responsible.
More industries
- Automotive Industry and Suppliers
- Food, Consumer Goods and Retail
- Construction and Building Materials
- Healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and Medical Technology
- Digital Economy and Platforms
- Telecommunications, IT and Technology
- Logistics, Transport and Mobility
- Industry and Mechanical Engineering
- Chemicals, Raw Materials and Basic Industries
- Banks, Financial Services and Insurance
- Agriculture and Agribusiness
Discuss your matter
Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.
The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.
