kartellrechtler.de › English

We Are Being Asked to Pay Cartel Damages

· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte

Deutsch · English · Français · Español

After a fining decision, purchasers, claims vehicles or associations come forward with damages claims. The amounts often exceed the fine. A well-planned defence combines legal objections, economics and a settlement strategy.

Lines of defence

  • Whether the claimant was affected: do the specific purchases fall within the product, period and territory of the cartel?
  • Amount of damage: counter-expert reports, alternative comparison methods, the influence of other price factors
  • Passing-on of the overcharge to the next level of the market
  • Limitation and standing to sue, especially for assigned claims
  • Joint and several liability and contribution claims against other cartel members
  • Privileges for immunity recipients and small and medium-sized enterprises

Strategy

Many cases end in a settlement. It is important that a settlement properly regulates the claims against the other cartel members (Section 33f GWB), so that you are not later faced with contribution claims. More: Cartel damages.

Practical examples

Practical example 1: Action by a claims vehicle with 1,500 assignors

A collection service provider sues on bundled claims of transport companies.

We challenged the validity of the assignments and the allocation of the purchases. A large part of the claims was dismissed.

Practical example 2: Counter-expert report on the amount of damage

A purchaser claims 18% of the purchase price.

Our economist showed that raw material costs largely explained the price increase. The court estimated the damage at a fraction of the claim.

Practical example 3: Settlement with protection against contribution claims

A cartel member wants to settle with its largest customer.

We structured the settlement so that the customer’s claim is reduced by the client’s share and other cartel members cannot claim contribution.

Practical example 4: Third-party notice to other cartel members

A company is sued alone, although five manufacturers were involved.

We served third-party notices on the other cartel members and secured the basis for the later internal settlement of contributions.

Frequently asked questions

Am I liable for the damage caused by all cartel members?

In principle yes; cartel members are jointly and severally liable. Whoever pays can seek contribution from the others. Exceptions apply to immunity recipients and, under certain conditions, to small and medium-sized enterprises.

Can I argue that the customer passed on the overcharge?

Yes. The passing-on defence is permitted. You must establish and prove that the purchaser passed the overcharge on to its own customers.

Is a settlement worthwhile?

Often yes, because expert reports and proceedings are expensive. It is essential that the settlement is structured under Section 33f GWB so that you do not pay again later through contribution claims of other cartel members.

More situations

Discuss your matter

Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.

The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.

Legal notice · Privacy · Terms of engagement (German)