· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte
Deutsch · English · Français · Español
A letter from a competition authority rarely comes out of the blue. Questionnaire, hearing or decision: deadlines are short, your answers shape the proceedings, and careless wording can hardly be withdrawn.
What kind of letter can arrive?
- Request for information or formal decision requiring information: questions on the market, customers and prices, often in merger reviews or sector inquiries, sometimes as a first step towards proceedings against you
- Hearing letter or statement of objections: the authority raises specific allegations and gives you the opportunity to respond
- Cease-and-desist or prohibition decision: the authority orders specific conduct
- Fining decision: in Germany, an objection must be lodged within two weeks of service
- Fee notice following a merger filing
What you should do now
Note the date of service and forward the complete letter to us. Do not answer substantive questions by telephone in advance. Secure the relevant documents and suspend deletion routines for affected mailboxes. For formal information decisions, we check which questions must be answered and where the company’s right to remain silent applies. More: Investigations and requests for information (German).
Practical examples
Practical example 1: Questionnaire in a merger review
A supplier receives a questionnaire about a planned merger of two of its customers.
We drafted the answers so that the client’s concerns about the merger became clear and prepared a redacted version for third parties. The authority required commitments to protect suppliers.
Practical example 2: Statement of objections from the Commission
A manufacturer is accused of having prevented dealers from selling across borders.
We obtained access to the file, submitted a reply with an economic analysis and presented it at the oral hearing. The allegation was limited to a shorter period.
Practical example 3: Fining decision against a managing director
A managing director receives a personal fine of EUR 80,000.
We lodged an objection in time and challenged the evidence. The Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf reduced the fine considerably.
Practical example 4: Complaint by a competitor
The authority informs a company that a competitor has complained about its rebates and asks for comments.
We explained the rebate system, supported it with a cost test and offered minor adjustments. The authority did not open proceedings.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to answer a request for information?
A formal decision requiring information is binding; incorrect or incomplete answers can be fined. A simple request is voluntary but should not be ignored without legal review.
How long do I have to object to a fining decision in Germany?
Two weeks from service. The objection can initially be lodged without reasons; after review by the Bundeskartellamt, the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf decides on it.
Can I obtain access to the file?
Yes. In German administrative and fine proceedings there is a right of access to the file; in Commission proceedings, after receipt of the statement of objections. Third parties‘ business secrets are redacted.
More situations
- The Competition Authority Is at the Door
- We Have Discovered an Infringement Internally
- We Have Been Harmed by a Cartel
- We Are Being Asked to Pay Cartel Damages
- A Business Partner Is Abusing Its Market Power
- We Are Planning an Acquisition or a Joint Venture
- We Want to Cooperate with a Competitor
- We Are Restructuring Our Distribution
- Tenders, Bidding Consortia and Exclusion from Public Contracts
- Investigations against Managers or Employees
Discuss your matter
Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.
The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.
