kartellrechtler.de › English

We Have Discovered an Infringement Internally

· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte

Deutsch · English · Français · Español

An e-mail, a tip via the whistleblowing system or a finding in due diligence: suddenly there is a suspicion that employees have colluded with competitors. Now time matters, because other participants could also go to the authority.

The right steps

  • Form a confidential team; the investigation should be led by lawyers
  • Secure data before the persons concerned are warned; suspend deletion routines
  • Stop the infringement without alerting competitors prematurely
  • Assess the leniency option immediately: only the first company receives full immunity from fines; a marker secures your place in the queue
  • Clarify employment law issues, in particular notice periods and duties to cooperate
  • Inform supervisory bodies, insurers and, where applicable, the parent company

Weighing the options

A leniency application means cooperating for years and full disclosure to the authority. It protects against fines, but not against damages claims; however, under German law the immunity recipient is in principle only liable to its own customers (Section 33e GWB). Together with you we assess the risk of detection, the evidence and the consequences in all countries concerned. See also Compliance and internal investigations.

Practical examples

Practical example 1: Chat group of sales managers

During an IT migration, the legal department comes across a messenger group in which sales managers of several competitors announced price increases.

On the same day we secured a marker with the Bundeskartellamt, forensically preserved the data and conducted interviews. The company received full immunity from fines.

Practical example 2: Discovery after an acquisition

After closing, the buyer discovers that the acquired company had been involved in collusion in previous years.

We ended the collusion, filed a leniency application and asserted claims against the seller under the warranties in the purchase agreement.

Practical example 3: Suspicion without clear evidence

A former employee claims there were customer allocation agreements. Initially, no evidence is found.

We carried out and documented a proportionate investigation. As the suspicion was not substantiated, no application was filed; the company can prove that it investigated diligently.

Practical example 4: Infringement in several countries

The collusion concerned customers in Germany, France and Poland.

We coordinated leniency applications with the European Commission and summary applications with the national authorities so that no ranking was lost.

Frequently asked questions

Does the leniency applicant always receive full immunity?

Only the first company to provide evidence before the authority has sufficient evidence of its own receives full immunity. Further applicants can obtain reductions if their evidence adds significant value.

Does leniency protect against damages claims?

No. Under German law, however, the immunity recipient is in principle only liable to its own direct and indirect customers and suppliers, not jointly and severally for the entire cartel damage.

Are we obliged to report the infringement to the authority?

There is no general duty to self-report. Management must, however, stop the infringement and carefully weigh the consequences; whether a leniency application is in the company’s interest is a case-by-case decision.

More situations

Discuss your matter

Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.

The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.

Legal notice · Privacy · Terms of engagement (German)