kartellrechtler.de › English

Cartels, Price Fixing and Leniency

· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte

Deutsch · English · Français · Español

Agreements between competitors on prices, quantities, customers or territories are the most serious infringements of competition law. Authorities pursue them with high fines, injured parties claim damages, and in tenders the individuals involved may also face criminal liability.

Legal basis

Section 1 GWB and Article 101(1) TFEU prohibit agreements and concerted practices between undertakings which have as their object or effect the restriction of competition. Price fixing, quotas and market sharing are restrictions by object: the authority does not have to prove concrete market effects. An exemption is practically excluded for such hardcore restrictions.

Form is irrelevant. A formal contract is not required; a conversation at a trade fair, a message in a chat group or the unilateral disclosure of future prices to a competitor who takes note of it is sufficient. Coordination on price components such as surcharges, discount frameworks or payment terms is also covered.

What companies risk

  • Fines of up to 10% of the group’s worldwide turnover in the preceding year
  • Fines against managers and employees of up to EUR 1 million in Germany, and imprisonment for bid rigging (Section 298 Criminal Code)
  • Damages claims by all direct and indirect customers, with a statutory presumption of harm
  • Nullity of the agreements, entry in the German competition register and possible exclusion from public contracts
  • Disgorgement of economic benefits by the authority

Our approach

When a possible infringement becomes known internally, the first week often decides the outcome. We secure the facts in a confidential investigation led by counsel, assess the evidence and examine whether a leniency application should be filed with the Bundeskartellamt, the European Commission and other authorities. If proceedings have already been opened, we take over the defence: access to the file, response to the objections, settlement negotiations and, if necessary, the appeal to the Higher Regional Court of Düsseldorf or the action before the General Court.

Case examples

Praxisbeispiel 1: Conversation at a trade fair

A sales manager meets two colleagues from competitors at a trade fair. Over dinner one mentions that list prices will rise by 6% at the turn of the year. Nobody objects. A few weeks later all three companies raise their prices by a similar amount.

According to the case law of the Court of Justice, a company that receives such information and remains on the market is presumed to take it into account. We advised the company to distance itself openly in writing, to document the incident and to prove its independent pricing. Because of indications of earlier contacts, a leniency application was also prepared.

Praxisbeispiel 2: Sharing customers in building materials trade

Two regional dealers agree not to actively approach each other’s existing customers. An employee leaving the company reports this through the Bundeskartellamt’s anonymous whistleblower system.

After the dawn raid we used all options for reducing the fine: cooperation with added value for the authority, settlement with a 10% reduction and recognition of a compliance programme introduced after the infringement.

Praxisbeispiel 3: Coordinated energy surcharge

Several logistics companies discuss in an association working group what an „appropriate“ energy surcharge should be.

Coordination on individual price components is price fixing. On our advice the association dissolved the working group, reviewed the minutes of past meetings and introduced a policy requiring a competition lawyer to attend meetings.

Praxisbeispiel 4: Supplier as an information hub

A manufacturer repeatedly receives information from its main retailer on the future prices of a competing retailer and passes it on.

Such hub-and-spoke arrangements are treated as a horizontal agreement between the retailers with the participation of the manufacturer. We reviewed the manufacturer’s internal communication channels, trained the key account team and introduced clear rules on which retailer information may be passed on internally.

Is a non-binding understanding also prohibited?

Yes. A concerted practice is sufficient. Whether the parties comply with the understanding or implement it at all is irrelevant for the infringement.

Further topics

Discuss your matter

Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.

The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.

Legal notice · Privacy · Terms of engagement (German)