· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte
Deutsch · English · Français · Español
In recent years the automotive industry has been the scene of some of Europe’s largest cartel cases, from the trucks cartel to collusion on emission cleaning technology. At the same time, electric mobility, software and new sales models are changing the value chain.
Typical issues
- Supply and development agreements between manufacturers and suppliers, price adjustment clauses, dependency
- Technical cooperation and standardisation, for example in charging infrastructure, batteries and software
- Distribution: agency models, authorised dealers, online sales
- Aftermarket: access of independent workshops to spare parts, tools and vehicle data; the EU block exemption for the motor vehicle aftermarket applies until 31 May 2028
- Cartel damages, for example from the trucks cartel
Special features
In 2021 the European Commission fined several manufacturers for colluding on the development of emission cleaning technology. This shows that technical cooperation can also be a cartel if it restricts competition for better technology. Suppliers that are highly dependent on individual manufacturers can rely on German rules protecting against relative market power.
Practical examples
Practical example 1: Price adjustment for raw material costs
A supplier of aluminium parts wants to pass on increased costs; the manufacturer refuses and threatens to delist it.
We documented the supplier’s dependency and negotiated a price adjustment clause based on a raw material index.
Practical example 2: Common charging standard
Several manufacturers want to develop a common protocol for charging stations.
We structured the standardisation process in line with the Horizontal Guidelines: open access, transparent procedures, fair licensing terms.
Practical example 3: Independent workshop and vehicle data
A workshop chain is denied access to diagnostic data for new models.
We enforced access on the basis of the guidelines on the motor vehicle block exemption and the type-approval rules.
Practical example 4: Fleet operator and the trucks cartel
A haulier bought several hundred trucks over 15 years.
We recorded the claims, obtained an expert report and settled with several manufacturers.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a separate block exemption for motor vehicle distribution?
The sale of new vehicles is governed by the general Vertical Block Exemption Regulation. For the aftermarket, i.e. spare parts, repair and maintenance, the Motor Vehicle Block Exemption Regulation also applies; it has been extended until 31 May 2028.
Are independent workshops entitled to vehicle data?
Yes, to a large extent. Manufacturers must give independent workshops access to repair and maintenance information; this follows from type-approval law and competition law.
How can truck purchasers claim damages from the trucks cartel?
By an action or settlement against the manufacturers involved. Claimants must show which vehicles were bought or leased during the cartel period; the amount is usually determined by expert reports.
More industries
- Food, Consumer Goods and Retail
- Construction and Building Materials
- Energy, Water and Municipal Utilities
- Healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and Medical Technology
- Digital Economy and Platforms
- Telecommunications, IT and Technology
- Logistics, Transport and Mobility
- Industry and Mechanical Engineering
- Chemicals, Raw Materials and Basic Industries
- Banks, Financial Services and Insurance
- Agriculture and Agribusiness
Discuss your matter
Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.
The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.
