· Editorial team: lawyers of horak. Rechtsanwälte
Deutsch · English · Français · Español
Hardly any other sector is so often the subject of cartel proceedings as construction. Public tenders, regional markets and close contacts between competitors create risks. Cement, ready-mixed concrete, asphalt and fire engines are just some examples of prosecuted cartels.
Typical issues
- Bid rigging, cover bids and compensation payments; criminal liability under Section 298 of the German Criminal Code
- Bidding consortia and construction joint ventures: when they are permissible
- Subcontracting and supply relationships with competitors
- Competition register, exclusion from public contracts and self-cleaning
- Building materials trade: local markets, merger control, price adjustment clauses
- Damages claims by public contracting authorities
Special features
In construction, competitors are often also partners, for example as subcontractors or in a joint venture. This is permitted, but requires clear rules on which information may be exchanged. Public contracting authorities increasingly analyse bids using data and report anomalies.
Practical examples
Practical example 1: Joint venture for a bridge
Two medium-sized construction companies want to bid as a joint venture.
We documented their capacities and limited the exchange of calculation data to the project.
Practical example 2: Investigation into cover bids
The public prosecutor is investigating employees of a civil engineering company.
We took over the corporate defence, coordinated the individual defence and filed a leniency application with the Bundeskartellamt.
Practical example 3: Municipality demands liquidated damages
A contracting authority claims 15% of the contract value because of participation in a cartel.
We examined whether each contract was affected and reached an agreement covering part of the contracts.
Practical example 4: Acquisition in building materials trading
A building materials dealer buys three branches of a competitor.
We supported the filing with drive-time analyses; clearance was granted without conditions.
Frequently asked questions
Is a construction joint venture between competitors permitted?
Yes, if the partners could not perform the contract alone or not economically, or if the joint venture makes economic sense for other reasons. Information exchange must be limited to the project.
Is bid rigging a criminal offence?
Yes, under Section 298 of the German Criminal Code, punishable by up to five years‘ imprisonment or a fine. The company also faces fines, damages claims and exclusion from tenders.
What are liquidated damages clauses in construction contracts?
Many public authorities agree that the contractor pays a fixed percentage of the contract value if it participated in a cartel. Such clauses are generally valid if proof of a lower damage remains possible.
More industries
- Automotive Industry and Suppliers
- Food, Consumer Goods and Retail
- Energy, Water and Municipal Utilities
- Healthcare, Pharmaceuticals and Medical Technology
- Digital Economy and Platforms
- Telecommunications, IT and Technology
- Logistics, Transport and Mobility
- Industry and Mechanical Engineering
- Chemicals, Raw Materials and Basic Industries
- Banks, Financial Services and Insurance
- Agriculture and Agribusiness
Discuss your matter
Describe your matter to us by e-mail or telephone, in English, French, Spanish or German. We usually respond within one working day with an initial assessment. The initial assessment is free of charge and non-binding. In the event of an ongoing dawn raid, please call us directly: 0511 35 73 56-0.
The information on this website is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice in an individual case. The case examples have been anonymised and simplified.
